OBAN Isawa GLD Driver Shaft Review

OBAN ISAWA GLD Golf Driver Shaft Review

By Russ Ryden, Fit2Score, A Dallas Fort Worth Club Fitter & Club Maker
The Highlands Performance Golf Center, Carrollton Texas 
and Daniel Spurling, PGA, Director of Player Development
Lonnie Poole Golf Course
Golf Digest Certified America’s 100 Best Club Fitters

My first impression of the new Isawa GLD is stunning. I have grown fond of Oban golf shafts for that very reason. You can spot them from a mile away. Their bright colors and well-placed shaft bands turn heads on the range and the course. I’ve always told my customers that if what they’re looking down at doesn’t inspire confidence, then they shouldn’t put it in their golf bag.  Oban certainly helps players there. The Isawa GLD is a time-tested design.  Soft mid and firm tip shafts are a great option for many players. If you’re ready to invest some money into your equipment and don’t have access to a professional Club Fitter this type of shaft would be a safe bet.

Most shafts will have different launch characteristics as they span through their weights and flexes. The GLD consistently produced similar flight through the 7 offerings. When paired with their appropriate players the shafts remained stable through on and off-center strikes and transmitted sufficient feel back up through the handle. It was notable that less skilled players, were able to more accurately identify where the strike was located on the club face while testing the GLD. They commented that they hadn’t had the ability to identify that in their previous clubs.  The torque numbers are exceptionally low for the price point Oban is offering its players. In the most laymen of terms the torque value is going to correlate with how bad your off-center strikes are going to be. When you see low shaft weight and low torque you can expect to pay big bucks. The Isawa starts with a softer butt section reenforced with a new proprietary carbon fiber material integration. There is a slight increase in stiffness in the upper mid-section around the 30in mark with the same bump in stiffness a little lower down the shaft in the extra stiff 60g and 70g shafts. I’m wondering if this is a nod to the very successful original Isawa from Oban released in 2015.

A fitted golf shaft is a platform for consistency. The fitter’s responsibility is to find the correct composition of golf club in order for the player to hit the center of the club face as consistently as their skill level will allow. I found, like the profile suggests, the GLD fits a wide variety of players. Where I see the GLD separate itself from similar shafts in its category is the butt section. When you have a stronger tip section you have to give up some rigidity somewhere else in order to translate feel back to the hands. In most cases it’s the butt section of the shaft that gets thinned out. Fitting players into the correct butt stiffness is the hardest part of club fitting because butt stiffness correlates with feel. Feel is the one thing you can’t teach. It’s organic and must be self-discovered. If you give a discerning player a shaft with too strong a butt section, they are going to tell you it feels boardy. The GLD is equipped with a softer butt section than a lot of shafts that are stronger on the bottom end. This is where it found a place in my fitting matrix. Oban has integrated a proprietary carbon fiber material to reenforce the weaker butt section of the GLD giving it exceptional energy transfer back to the players hands. I have the most success fitting the Isawa GLD with players who have back swings short of parallel. A short backswing usually denotes a quick transition and faster tempo. These swing characteristics put more stress on a shaft. When you add speed to that mix you automatically start to consider stronger shafts. I wouldn’t describe the GLD as a strong golf shaft but it certainly feels softer than it plays. The weaker butt section of the GLD provides exceptional feel to players while allowing them to venture into a stronger tip than they are used to.  I recommend the GLD to players who have faster than average tempos who are looking for enhanced feel from a stronger mid launch mid spin shaft.
Daniel Spurling

To continue reading this section of the review, you must be registered at a higher level membership.
Russ

Mitsubishi Fubuki J Golf Shaft

Mitsubishi Fubuki J Driver Shaft

By Russ Ryden, Fit2Score, A Dallas Fort Worth Club Fitter & Club Maker
The Golf Center at the Highlands, Carrollton Texas

MRC_FubukiJ_Image
The fourth generation Fubuki, the Fubuki J, released to Mitsubishi Golf Club Fitters in June of 2014. It is still in play, the unique pattern was hard to miss in the final round of the 2016 Open. The Fubuki J is an update of the second generation Fubuki, the Fubuki Alpha. I see the Fubuki family as two different profiles and discussed them in an earlier article. Here is a quick overview of the two profiles.

MRC_Fubuki_TourvsK The original Fubuki Tour and the Fubuki K,introduced a few years later, are very much like the Diamana White and the second generation White, the ‘ahina. The third generation White, the Diamana ‘W” series is a different profile. The Fubuki Tour was discontinued in 2014. The Fubuki K is still in the product line.
MRC_Fubuki_AvsJThe second generation Fubuki Alpha and the fourth generation Fubuki J are also the same profile. They similar yet subtly different than the Diamana ‘ilima and the KuroKage Proto TINI. The differences make these unique designs that must be tested to find your best fit.

 

To continue reading this section of the review, you must be registered at a higher level membership.
Russ

Aldila Rogue I/O Golf Shaft Review

Aldila Rogue 110 MSI I/O Driver Shafts

By Russ Ryden, Fit2Score, A Dallas Fort Worth Club Fitter & Club Maker
The Golf Center at the Highlands, Carrollton Texas

Rogue_IO_ImageIOTipLogoThe Aldila Rogue I/O is an update the the Rogue Silver. The tip section of the shaft has a notation, RIP I/O. The tip section of the Rogue I/o is made with Aldila’s RIP technology. RIP (Reverse Interlaminar Placement) means some of the bias wraps are moved from the core of the shaft to the outer wall. Outer layers of material exert a greater influence on tube performance than inner layers. The bias (angular) wraps of material create torsional and hoop strength in a tube. Moving those layers to the exterior of the shaft generally means lower torque and higher hoop strength. In the Rogue I/O the torque and hoop strength of the original Rogue Silver shafts are matched in the Rogue Silver RIP in a 5 to 9 gram lighter shaft.

The technical discussion and measurements are available only to registered readers

- Golf Professional Notes -

Dynamic Gold AMT – Tour Issue – Golf Shaft Review

Dynamic Gold AMT Iron Shafts

By Russ Ryden and Mark Maness

By Russ Ryden, Fit2Score, A Dallas Fort Worth Club Fitter & Club Maker
The Golf Center at the Highlands, Carrollton Texas

DGAMT_Image

AMT stands for Ascending Mass Technology. It is not a new concept. Ping has had ascending weight shafts for many years. Nippon 999’s were ascending. Aerotech Players Spec were ascending. If you are not a club maker you probably have not been exposed to the concept. Briefly, there are primarily two kinds of shafts; constant weight tapers and parallel’s. Constant weight tapers are made to length in the factory and the shafts in the set are all the same weight even though they are different lengths. Parallels are made to one length in the factory. The club maker cuts them to the length needed for the club he is building. As they are cut shorter they weigh less. The shafts in a set are lighter in the short irons than in the long irons.  I wrote an article about this some years ago in the technical stuff section of this site; Constant Weight vs Parallel Iron Shafts.

Iron heads get heavier as the the numbers get higher. The 4 iron head is heavier than the 3 iron, the 5 iron is heavier than the 4 iron and so on down to the gap wedge. In sets made of parallel shafts, the shafts get lighter while the head gets heavier. In sets made from constant weight shafts, the shafts are the same weight while the heads get heavier. In ASCENDING WEIGHT sets, the shafts get heavier as the heads get heavier. This has always been an attraction the club builders that create MOI, Moment of Inertia, matched sets.

The technical discussion, measurements and testing results are available only to registered readers

This is a great step forward in iron shaft technology. Keep it coming, True Temper, the club building community has waited a long time for a set of iron shafts like this!

Mitsubishi KuroKage XM Driver Shaft Review

Mitsubishi KuroKage XM Driver

By Russ Ryden, Fit2Score, A Dallas Fort Worth Club Fitter & Club Maker
The Golf Center at the Highlands, Carrollton Texas

KKXM_Image
Some shafts are simply too good to change. The Mitsubishi KuroKage Proto TiNi is one such shaft. The new KuroKage XM is the KuroKage Proto with new graphics and a wider range of weights. It is promoted as a mid launch – mid spin shaft. I view launch and spin as a propensity not an absolute. Your angle of attack, the club head loft,  where you strike and how the shaft, interacting with your loading and release, deliver the head are all part of the launch and spin equation. The XM, in the right hands, is not what I would define as mid launch / mid spin. But, shaft companies have to fill in those words for the golfing public.

The Mitsubishi website has always presented shaft EI graphics alongside their verbal descriptions. If you spend years looking at those charts and testing them on a wide range of golfers they being to have meaning. I view the difference between the KuroKage XM and the KuroKage XT as more feel related than launch. The XT has a stiffness bump low mid. That bump does contribute to a lower launch, but more important, gives a better sense of tip stability to a hard swinging late release golfer.

The technical discussion, measurements and testing results are available only to registered readers

To continue reading this section of the review, you must be registered at a higher level membership.
Russ

Project X HZDRUS Yellow Golf Shaft Review

Project X HZRDUS Yellow Driver Shaft

By Russ Ryden, Fit2Score, A Dallas Fort Worth Club Fitter & Club Maker
The Golf Center at the Highlands, Carrollton Texas

HZDRUS Yellow Image
The Project X HZRDUS Yellow is the third driver shaft in the Hand Crafted family from True Temper. It has a notably soft midsection. This is much like the first in the series, the Project X Loading Zone reviewed earlier. The bend profile is much like the profiles of the 70 gram versions of the Project X Loading Zone model. The soft zones of those shafts moved with weight and flex. I have fit a number of players into the 50 and 60 gram versions of the Loading Zone. Therefore, another shaft with that design grabbed my attention.

I had a chance just recently to test it during a fitting with a single digit handicap player that showed up with a 6 year old driver and a 103 mph golf swing. Working with the Yellow HZRDUS and a TaylorMade M1 we added 2 mph to his swing speed, 3 mph to his ball speed, dropped his spin 800 rpm all of which added 17 yards to his drives. His playing buddies are in for a surprise.

To continue reading this section of the review, you must be registered at a higher level membership.
Russ